FPLAIInsights
Captain25 April 2026

GW35 Captain Picks: Haaland Away at Everton or Salah at Old Trafford — Who Gets the Armband?

With Gameweek 35 fast approaching, three names dominate the captaincy conversation. Haaland carries the weight of 58.2% ownership into a tricky Everton away fixture, Salah arrives at a defensively shaky Man United side with elite form, and Watkins offers a high-ceiling differential against Tottenham at Villa Park. Here is what the data says.

Erling HaalandMCI FWD - £14.5m
Form: 5.0Owned: 58.2%Fixture: MCI away EVEDifficulty: 4 (home) / 3 (away)

Haaland is the safe, popular choice but Everton at home carry a difficulty rating of 4, making this a tougher assignment than his ownership suggests. His form of 5.0 is solid yet slightly behind the in-form pack, and captaining him is the low-risk differential play only if you fear a differential blowing up.

CAPTAIN — 68%
Mohamed SalahLIV MID - £14.0m
Form: 6.0Owned: 14.9%Fixture: LIV away MUNDifficulty: 3 (home) / 4 (away)

Salah's form of 6.0 leads this trio and Man United have struggled defensively all season, giving him a genuine route to a big haul at Old Trafford. At just 14.9% ownership, captaining Salah is a strong differential move that could swing your rank considerably in either direction.

DIFFERENTIAL CAPTAIN — 78%
Ollie WatkinsAVL FWD - £8.8m
Form: 6.0Owned: 15.9%Fixture: AVL home TOTDifficulty: 2

Watkins matches Salah's form at 6.0 and faces the best fixture of any captain option this week, with Villa hosting Tottenham at a difficulty of just 2. At 15.9% ownership and nearly half the price of Haaland, he is the contrarian pick that offers the greatest potential rank jump at the lowest cost.

CONTRARIAN CAPTAIN — 82%

Want personalised FPL advice based on your squad and rank?

Get Your AI Briefing